The real truth about Growth Hormone for Anti-Aging and Sports. It's Quackery and Hucksterism.
As detailed on this website, human growth hormone (hGH) for many good reasons is illegal for anti-aging, athletic enhancement and age-related diseases, just like anabolic steroids are illegal for body-building and athletic enhancement.
Claims that human growth hormone and substances that stimulate its production work to stop or reverse aging or build strength are unfounded and the marketing of these substances for such purposes constitutes quackery and hucksterism. On the other side of the coin are the risks of arthritis, diabetes and cancer, and actually lower life expectancy.
In the U.S. Congressional report, "Quackery: A $10 Billion Scandal”, a quack is defined as: "...anyone who promotes medical schemes or remidies known to be false or that are unproven for a profit."
See the menu to the left for specific topics ranging from the legal/FDA, medical literature to convicted pharmacies and physicians to deaths
AntiAgingQuackery.com Featured on CNN and in Newsweek
BY TERI THOMPSON and MICHAEL O'KEEFFE DAILY NEWS SPORTS WRITERS
Friday, March 28th 2008, 4:00 AM
Three men affiliated with a Florida anti-aging clinic at the heart of Major League Baseball's steroid scandal pleaded guilty Thursday to drug-related charges in Albany County (N.Y.) District Court.
Glen Stephanos, the co-owner of the Palm Beach Rejuvenation Center, pleaded guilty to one count of criminal sale of a controlled substance, a felony. Under the terms of his plea bargain, Stephanos faces five years' probation, must forfeit $350,000 and will testify against the remaining defendants arrested in Albany District Attorney David Soares' "Operation Which Doctor."
His brother, PBRC marketing director George Stephanos, and PBRC employee Ryan Dumas pleaded guilty to conspiracy, a misdemeanor. Both men agreed to pay a $1,000 fine and testify against other defendants.
According to the Mitchell Report on doping in baseball, the Palm Beach Rejuvenation Center supplied human growth hormone and steroids to several baseball players, including Cleveland Indians pitcher Paul Byrd, who bought nearly $25,000 worth of HGH in 13 transactions between August 2002 and January 2005.
About The Author: Tom Perls MD, MPH is an Associate Professor of Medicine at Boston University School of Medicine and is a practicing geriatrician at Boston Medical Center. Dr. Perls is the Founder and Co-Director of the New England Centenarian Study. He is board-certified in Internal Medicine (residency: Harbor UCLA Medical Center) and Geriatrics (fellowships: Harvard Medical School and Mount Royal Hospital in Melbourne Australia). He earned his MPH at the Harvard School School of Public Health and he is a Fellow of the American College of Physicians. Dr.Perls became interested in becoming a vocal critic of the anti-aging industry when he noted the pernicious and deceitful picture of older people painted by many anti-aging clinics, websites and hucksters. Such marketing promotes terrible and completely unwarranted biases. Learning more about the most popularized treatment, Dr. Perls realized that the promotion of GH is unquestionably dangerous and illegal quackery.
You can reach Dr. Perls via email at thperls@bu.edu or 617-638-6688
The House of Representatives Committee on Oversight and Government Reform’s recent hearing: Myths and Facts about Human Growth Hormone, B12, and Other Substances. February 12, 2008.
Committee Holds Hearing on Myths and Facts about Human Growth Hormone, B12, and Other Substances
Witnesses testify to shed light on controversial substances
By Bryan Hoch / MLB.com
WASHINGTON -- Just 24 hours before Roger Clemens and Brian McNamee were scheduled to occupy the same room on Capitol Hill, four expert witnesses testified to shed additional light on several sometimes-mysterious and often-misconstrued substances at the heart of the Mitchell Report.
The Committee on Oversight and Government Reform held a hearing Tuesday regarding "Myths and Facts about Human Growth Hormone, B-12 and Other Substances," in Room 2154 of the Rayburn House Office Building.
In an opening statement, chairman Henry Waxman (D-Calif.) said that nothing has surprised him more in the committee's ongoing investigations than the public's confusion regarding steroids, human growth hormone, vitamin B-12 and other substances.
"Senator Mitchell's report on the use of performance-enhancing substances in baseball found that the use of human growth hormone by professional baseball players is rising," Waxman said. "Just last week, Sylvester Stallone seemed to be endorsing the use of HGH [in a published interview] to reverse the aging process.
"It is an unfortunate reality that what professional athletes and celebrities do serves as a health guide to millions of Americans. Even worse, there seems to be an almost unlimited number of unscrupulous scam artists ready to exploit this reality."
A cursory glance at several Web sites reveals an easy-to-access array of products that claim to be able to reverse the aging process, enhance physical performance and boost energy. An isolated Google search performed Tuesday for "human growth hormone" yielded more than 7.6 million results, many of them highly dubious sales pitches.
"The committee's three-year, bipartisan investigation of performance-enhancing substance abuse in professional sports uncovered an industry dangerously tolerant of pseudo-science and medical mischief in its locker rooms," Rep. Tom Davis (R-Va.) said. "The Mitchell Report added to that picture, making it clear that while steroid use continues to be a concern, the newest trend is HGH abuse, alleged to speed recovery from injuries and build lean muscle mass."
Key to the discussion was the definition and use of HGH, which will be at the forefront of Wednesday's proceedings. McNamee, Clemens' former personal trainer, has alleged that Clemens -- a seven-time Cy Young Award winner who owns 354 Major League victories -- used the drug along with steroids as part of his training regimen beginning in 1998.
When medically necessary, the panel indicated, HGH can be a safe and effective clinical treatment for children and adults. Legitimate uses for HGH include promoting linear growth in short children, and it has been approved by the United States Food and Drug Administration for conditions such as growth hormone deficiency, chronic kidney disease, Turner syndrome and muscle wasting due to HIV or AIDS.
Such cases are relatively rare. Dr. Alan Rogol, professor of clinical pediatrics at the University of Virginia and the Indiana University School of Medicine, said that cases of growth hormone deficiency, for example, average one in every 4,000 persons, while Turner syndrome averages one in every 2,500 girls.
Certainly, a Major League player like Clemens -- or Andy Pettitte and Chuck Knoblauch, who did not refute their inclusion in the Mitchell Report and provided testimony -- would not qualify under any of those criteria.
For healthy, normally aging individuals, a Stanford University review of 31 clinical studies found the only benefit to be a slight increase in muscle mass. Documented negative side effects included soft tissue swelling, joint pains, carpal tunnel-like syndrome, breast enlargement and diabetes.
The risks increase because, as Dr. Todd Schlifstein of the New York University Medical Center said, HGH users typically do not use the drug alone. Combinations with anabolic steroids are common and allow users to see greater short-term gains -- such as a "ripped," muscular effect -- while also increasing their chances at harmful long-term effects.
"The combined use increases muscle strength, speed and size," Dr. Schlifstein said. "Studies have had mixed results when comparing the performance-enhancing benefits of using HGH and steroids versus using steroids alone."
No long-term clinical studies have been conducted on the effects of HGH use in healthy adults or in anyone at doses exceeding FDA-approved levels. For these reasons and others, Dr. Thomas T. Perls of the Boston University School of Medicine has recommended that HGH be classified as a Schedule III controlled substance in the United States, much like anabolic steroids.
"There are a number of safe and legitimate FDA-approved uses of growth hormone in adults and children," said Dr. Rogol. "The off-label use of growth hormone, which is primarily in the anti-aging and body image or athletic market, comes with increased risks."
Many users are unaware of correct dosage. Higher HGH dosages may achieve levels similar to those found in the endocrine disease acromegaly, which is caused by too much growth hormone in the body. This condition may lead to severe muscle weakness and heart disease. Professional wrestler Andre the Giant is one well-known person who suffered from acromegaly.
"Though there are a number of legitimate reasons to administer human growth hormone, these do not include anti-aging or 'improvement' in athletic performance," Rogol said. "People who misuse this drug run the risk of seriously damaging their health."
Dr. Rogol said that some athletes and others may not even be purchasing or receiving legitimate HGH, leaving them to inject unknown substances into their bodies. Compounds falsely sold as HGH -- which can only be injected, not taken orally, a common misconception -- may also promote the growth of tumors due to unlisted ingredients.
"Best case, gullible people are only being scammed out of their money," Davis said. "Worst case, they are placing their health in the hands of criminals who could be operating beyond the reach of our laws anywhere in the world."
Also central to the topic of drugs in professional sports is the continuing use of the injectable vitamin B-12, notably concerning Clemens, Rafael Palmeiro and Miguel Tejada. When McNamee charged that he injected Clemens on at least 16 occasions with steroids or HGH, Clemens insisted that he had only received injections of B-12 and Lidocaine, a localized short-lasting painkiller, from his personal trainer.
Palmeiro claimed, after testing positive for steroids and being suspended in 2005, that he had only injected himself with B-12, which he said he acquired from Tejada.
While panel experts bristled at the idea of an unlicensed person injecting a client using needles and syringes, would the B-12 even have done Clemens any good, other than as a red, syrupy placebo?
"It seems like a benign drug," Schlifstein said, "but let's remember, it is a drug."
Experts testify that B-12 is useful for those who suffer from pernicious anemia or have difficulty absorbing B-12 from food or tablets. Still, the widely-held belief that B-12 injections increase energy, fight off colds and generally promote good health appears to be a myth.
"All of these are true when persons deficient in vitamin B-12 are treated," said Dr. Susan B. Shurin, deputy director of the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute. "However, there is no evidence at all of those clinical benefits when the vitamin is given to persons who are not deficient."
Davis expressed hope that hearings like Tuesday's would continue to pave a path toward eradicating harmful substances and confusion regarding these topics from the American public.
"We have to find a way to block transmission of that false incentive and convince young athletes there are no magic pills or wonder drugs that will grease the path to the Hall of Fame," Davis said. "Only hard work, and the most effective antidote to illicit drugs -- the truth -- should fuel the bodies and minds of those seeking athletic excellence at any level."
Bryan Hoch is a reporter for MLB.com. This story was not subject to the approval of Major League Baseball or its clubs.
Growth Hormones Flex Little Muscle
Athletes Who Take Human Growth Hormones for Competitive Edge Derive Little Benefit, Studies Show
March 18, 2008 -- Athletes who risk their careers and reputations by taking human growth hormones may be getting little in return, a new research review suggests.
Combined results from 27 studies did not support the claim that taking human growth hormones boosts athletic performance.
Short-term use of growth hormones was associated with increases in lean body mass, but not improvements in strength.
And there was even some suggestion that human growth hormone worsened exercise performance.
The studies were small and of short duration, with the longest lasting just 84 days.
Larger, longer studies are needed to conclusively determine whether growth hormone improves athletic performance, and if so, at what cost, researcher Hau Liu, MD, MPH, tells WebMD.
"Based on the current literature, we found no evidence that human growth hormones improved exercise capacity or athletic performance," he says.
Human Growth Hormone Studies
Human growth hormone is produced naturally in the body, and is essential for growth and development. A synthetic version, available since 1985, is used to treat growth hormone deficiency and other medical conditions.
Athletes take it in the belief that growth hormones will improve their performance and help them recover more quickly from injury.
But they are acting on faith, because the research doesn't prove these claims, Liu says.
The studies reviewed by Liu and colleagues from California’s Santa Clara Valley Medical Center and Stanford University included 303 physically fit healthy people -- mostly young men -- given growth hormone treatment either by injection or infusion.
The participants were followed for one month to just under three months to determine if the growth hormone affected body composition, strength, metabolism, and exercise capacity.
Although growth hormone use did seem to lead to increases in lean body mass, it did not appear to improve muscle strength.
And Liu says two of three studies examining exercise performance showed growth-hormone-treated patients had higher lactate levels than untreated control subjects, which could be indicative of diminished exercise capacity. Growth-hormone-treated participants also reported more fatigue.
The study appears in the May 20 issue of the Annals of Internal Medicine, but it was released online today.
"More research, including identification and evaluation of the real-world growth hormone doping protocols, is warranted to definitively determine the effects of growth hormone on athletic performance," they write.
Spotlight on Performance-Enhancing Drugs
Like anabolic steroids, growth hormone is banned by the World- and U.S. Anti-Doping Agency, the Olympic Committee, and most major and amateur sports leagues.
While steroid use can be detected though a simple urine test, this is not the case with growth hormones.
As a result, it is not at all clear how widespread growth hormone use is among student and professional athletes.
"The estimates have been from just about everyone to almost nobody," U.S. Anti-Doping Agency senior managing director Larry Bowers, PhD, tells WebMD. "We just don't know."
Mainstream Docs Join Anti-Aging Bandwagon
Brian Alexander MSNBC contributor
POSTED: 9:56 am EDT April 21, 2008
UPDATED: 1:43 pm EDT April 21, 2008
For thousands of years, magicians, alchemists, even a few fringe medical practitioners have fueled an unbounded optimism that we can blunt the ravages of time, stay younger for longer, maybe even defeat death itself. Their pitches have usually hinged on some drug, food or device - everything from electricity to yogurt to surgically installing the gonads of animals into our own bodies - that will slow or reverse the aging process. Every decade or so, "anti-aging" promoters grasp onto news coming out of research labs and trumpet those developments as the answer we have all been awaiting.
Lately, the buzzwords are "nano," which refers to the science of the ultra small (a nanometer is one millionth of a millimeter), and stem cells. One "nano" face cream, for example, promises to stave off wrinkles with "nano-encapsulated technology" into which the makers have "packed microscopic bundles of Prodew, a nourishing skin humectant." A dietary supplement advertised as "The World's FIRST Stem Cell Enhancer," promises to "Rebuild, Renew, Rejuvenate" - giving you more stem cells and keeping your organs healthy - if you take the blue-green algae capsules. The claims are based on wispy science and hype.
But while the cycle remains the same, something new is happening in the world of anti-aging. Mainstream doctors who once wanted nothing to do with the naturopaths, osteopaths and others who first populated modern anti-aging, and whom they often considered glorified carnival barkers, are buying in, signing up for "certification" as anti-aging practitioners and offering patients the promise of youth and rejuvenation through such treatments as human growth hormone, testosterone, special diet and exercise regimens, antioxidants and hundreds of other supplements.
"It is mushrooming," says Dr. Elliot Snyder, an emergency room physician based in Northern California who follows the movement closely by frequently attending anti-aging meetings and talking to friends in the field. He also uses some of its techniques himself. Besides exercising five days a week and following a strict low-fat diet that includes lots of fruits, vegetables and wild salmon but no white flour or red meat, he takes supplements ranging from thiamin and biotin to DHEA, DMAE, colostrum, arginine, carnitine and omega-3 fatty acids - about 50 pills per day. He is 64 but looks a decade younger.
Back in 1994, the annual Las Vegas meeting of the fledgling XXX was held in a small hotel off the Las Vegas strip. Everyone could fit into a temporary tent-like structure on the pool patio. Last December, at the 15th XXXX confab, roughly 2,000 attendees, including business owners, anti-aging promoters and hundreds of doctors - among them obstetricians, ER docs, psychiatrists and internists - filled a cavernous meeting space inside the Venetian Hotel and Resort.
Today, claims Dr. XX, XXX's co-founder, there are about 20,000 XXX-certified doctors around the world. XXXX's tax returns confirm the boom. The income from fees charged to those seeking board certification from XXXX more than doubled from $544,845 in 2005 to $1.2 million in 2006.
A rival organization, Age Management Medicine Group, is growing rapidly, too, says co-founder Rick Merner. He claims the group had more than 400 doctors at its last meeting, sponsored by the nation's single largest "age-management" clinic, Cenegenics. The Cenegenics Foundation also certifies practitioners in age-management medicine (it shuns the term "anti-aging") and claims to have experienced a 100 percent increase in the number of its physician "affiliates" to more than 800.
Mainstream business has recognized the potential. GE Healthcare, for example, sent a team to the recent XXXX meeting to market body scanners that cost about $100,000 each and are often used by anti-aging doctors to look at fat deposits inside the body and convince patients of the need to do something about them. (Msnbc.com is a joint venture of Microsoft and NBC Universal, which is a GE company.)
'A life-changing experience' Patients all over the country are buying in. Rebecca Gooden, a 57-year-old Charleston, S.C., real estate agent, first saw an anti-aging doctor in December when she sought help for joint pain, insomnia and lack of energy. "I had felt something was going on but standard testing did not show any of it," she says. "I had been having symptoms but doctors kept telling me there was nothing wrong and I knew there was." Frustrated, when she saw an article about Cenegenics in a magazine, she called for an appointment in hopes of solving her problems. Now, she spends about $1,000 a month on hormones and supplements to treat various hormonal deficiencies and has become an anti-aging convert. "I feel like a new person ... it has been a life-changing experience for me."
All this despite the fact that as far as the American Medical Association or the American Board of Medical Specialties is concerned, there is no such thing as an anti-aging specialty.
Therein lies the often bitter tension between the medical establishment and those physicians and organizations who say they can help us slow or even stop the aging process and the debilitation that comes with it. Goldman and his XXX co-founder, Dr. XXX, have been accused by respected academics of being snake-oil salesmen. Cenegenics and A4M have both been labeled glorified hormone-pushers.
Anti-aging advocates, on the other hand, argue that they are a persecuted minority of enlightened medical professionals who have the patients' best interests at heart and that the AMA, the mainstream media and the government, especially the Food and Drug Administration, have conspired to keep the truth from the public.
"Certain vested interests would not like to have anti-aging," XX argues.
To the ears of Northwestern University bioethics professor Laurie Zoloth, this sounds like an old story. "Whenever one hears these things, that there is a conspiracy against patients, if you come to us we will tell you truth, then one has to ask, 'Why are your statements credible?'"
Has anti-aging 'arrived'? That is precisely the question many consumers are now being asked to answer for themselves. If their M.D. is signing onto anti-aging, does that mean the message is now credible? Does the certificate on his or her wall mean that real anti-aging has, at last, arrived? Or does it simply mean that every patient now has one more reason to live by the Latin phrase caveat emptor - buyer beware?
Dr. Thomas Perls, a Boston University researcher who studies centenarians (people who live at least 100 years), and a vociferous critic of the anti-aging industry, argues that while some anti-aging practitioners "may have their hearts in the right place ... in my mind the whole anti-aging practice has so many problems of ethical and professional misconduct. These practices are selling medicines and substances at great profit with very little in the way of clinical studies to support what they are doing."
The answers to the science questions can be complicated, but the motivations of some doctors to enter the anti-aging world are not. Dr. Arnold Relman, a former editor of The New England Journal of Medicine who is now a professor emeritus of medicine and social medicine at Harvard Medical School, believes "the interest in anti-aging practice is mainly based on economic considerations" by physicians who are looking to boost income.
"Get your piece of the $50 billion anti-aging marketplace!" trumpets a flyer distributed to doctors at XX's Las Vegas meeting. An article by X and X in "Medical Spas," a magazine that's a member of XX, encourages doctors to open their own medical spas and to have them certified under the World Council for Clinical Accreditation, another XXX organization, because "a single anti-aging patient is estimated to bring $4,000 to $20,000 in annual gross revenue."
The business can be very good, indeed. Doctors can count on regular hours because the patients are not sick. Better yet, patients pay cash because visits and procedures are not generally covered by insurance, which also means there is no upper limit to fees. And since there is no need to deal with insurance companies or HMOs, practices do not require extra staff to handle all that paperwork.
Additionally, anti-aging doctors often sell lines of creams and supplements, such as vitamins, antioxidants and plant extracts, which claim to do everything from strengthening the immune system to boosting libido, directly out of their offices, sometimes with an enormous mark-up. They can also use their own in-office technology, like those GE body scanners, to charge for in-house testing.
Patients generally see anti-aging doctors much more often than regular physicians. That's because in addition to checking on measures like weight and body fat and how patients are feeling overall, the docs are constantly monitoring a large range of sometimes esoteric health indicators with a battery of medical tests, including urinalysis and blood work. They look for levels of everything from testosterone and estrogen to follicle stimulating hormone and dehydroepiandrosterone (a natural steroid known as DHEA). Based on all these results, the doctors may then recommend drugs, hormones, supplements and special diets and fitness regimens - and then set an appointment to see the patient again in several weeks or months for another cash-only check-up.
One doctor, two hats Dr. Andrew Jurow, an ob-gyn in Burlingame, Calif., says he started an anti-aging practice alongside his ongoing traditional practice after becoming a devotee himself. "I am as mainstream as you can get. I am 59 years old, board certified in ob-gyn, as was my father. If you had come to me five, six years ago and talked about anti-aging, I would have said, 'Hogwash!'"
But then Jurow, long an avid exerciser, attended an A4M meeting and came away impressed with what he heard. Five years ago he began visiting an anti-aging doctor himself. Now he sees his regular ob-gyn HMO patients through one door of his building and anti-aging patients through another.
Jurow says he is not getting rich off his anti-aging patients. Rather, his motivation is his own belief that it works. Still, he says, if he sees an anti-aging patient for an hour, he can charge $350, whereas HMOs might reimburse him as little as $50 for a traditional office visit.
Dr. Mickey Barber, a Charleston, S.C., Cenegenics affiliate and Gooden's physician, was an anesthesiologist before turning to "age management" medicine five years ago. She believes that mainstream medicine "at one point in time was lucrative, but it is less so now with health insurance, litigation, and many doctors became discouraged. I think doctors are looking for another way to provide medical care for patients, and if part of that pays the bills, sure."
A typical evaluation of a new patient in Barber's clinic, she says, takes about seven hours and she may order up to 90 laboratory tests. The day costs $3,000.
Johnny Adams, a 58-year-old software consultant in Newport Beach, Calif., has experienced the way some anti-aging doctors bump fees by prescribing and testing. He has spent between $1,400 and $2,000 per year for the last four years on anti-aging, but that represents a big drop in his costs.
When he first began, he says, he tried a number of doctors. "One had me on a very overly aggressive and rather na¯ve program. He had me on everything under the sun. Pretty soon I was taking something like 178 different nutritional supplements, hormones, some prescription drugs I was getting from overseas." Now he focuses on nutrition, exercise and some supplements such as omega-3s, antioxidants and vitamins.
The anti-aging field's emphasis on supplements comes even though there is little evidence that most do anything for people who already eat a healthy diet. "I know it's possible that I'm just giving myself expensive pee," says Snyder, the ER doc, laughing.
Unlike manufacturers of prescription and over-the-counter medications, dietary supplement makers do not have to prove their products are safe or effective before selling them. Some supplements have been shown to be contaminated with lead or other harmful substances. And research has even found that large doses of antioxidants, like beta-carotene, actually increase cancer risks.
Hormones are hot But hormones are the most popular tools in anti-aging's armory. Scientists recognized their potential over 100 years ago, but their use in modern anti-aging traces back to July 1990 when a researcher named Daniel Rudman published a study about the effects of human growth hormone (HGH) on men over 60 in The New England Journal of Medicine.
Though the anti-aging industry existed long before then, Texas entrepreneur Howard Turney, who now calls himself Lazarus Long after an immortal character in a Robert Heinlein novel, created a new version. He was so enthused about Rudman's positive results that he started a resort called El Dorado in Cancun, Mexico, to administer HGH to those seeking rejuvenation. XX, then an osteopath and a consultant at El Dorado, held the XXX's organizing meeting there.
Rudman issued many caveats and cautions about using HGH and never recommended its use to delay aging. In fact, he was horrified his study was being used to support the industry especially since heavy use of growth hormone can have unwanted side effects. Endocrinologists worry that unnecessarily taking HGH could trigger cancers, diabetes and other hormone-related conditions. There are still many unknowns.
Still, HGH, the body's "master hormone," became the hottest thing to hit anti-aging since vitamin C because it was a real drug that appeared to restore youthful vigor.
**** wrote a 1996 book, "Grow Young with HGH," summing up the life-extension world's hope that there was finally a fountain of youth in a bottle. He dedicated it to Rudman saying, "His vision and pioneering human research with growth hormone for anti-aging marked the beginning of the end of aging."
Now that sports doping scandals have made HGH, as well as testosterone and other hormones, front-page news, and some anti-aging clinics and compounding pharmacies have been raided by the U.S. Drug Enforcement Agency for being overly liberal with hormone prescriptions, the anti-aging community has toned down its endorsement of hormones, at least in public.
"Less than 10 percent of patients involved in anti-aging are receiving growth hormone," Klatz insists.
That seems a dubious assertion. In fact, hormones remain a key ingredient of anti-aging practice. "Most of my anti-aging patients get hormones," typically growth hormone as well as sex hormones appropriate to each gender, Jurow says.
In his own article in "Medical Spas," XX argues that one of the main reasons for an M.D. to partner with a med spa is to "offer patients ... Bio-Identical Hormone Replacement Therapy, which aims to arrest age-related declines in hormone levels such that the natural peaks achieved in youth are maintained throughout life."
Yet there is no evidence that people live longer if they take HGH - lab animals with less growth hormone actually live longer than their normal brethren - or any other hormone. Nor is there any conclusive proof hormones make healthy older people any healthier. Research results are mixed, the picture murky.
The recent death of Cenegenics founder Dr. Alan Mintz, a prime HGH promoter, demonstrates that growth hormone is no panacea. He died last June, at age 69, reportedly during a brain biopsy.
As some enthusiasts admit, anti-aging patients are essentially running a giant uncontrolled experiment on themselves - increasingly at the hands of doctors.
Critics point out that the biggest concern about doctors getting involved is that many patients incorrectly assume that if their trusted physician is recommending hormones and supplements, these treatments must be safe and effective.
The fact is, no drug, treatment or supplement has ever been shown to extend human lifespan.
But Gooden, the Charleston real estate agent, calls her own transformation at the hands of Barber "a miracle."
"For as long as I can remember I have had insomnia," she says. "And increasing pain that doctors said was arthritis." Barber's daylong testing, however, "showed what needed to be dealt with," mainly deficiencies in DHEA, estrogen and testosterone. "My hormonal levels were way out of whack, my cardiac function was not what it should be," Gooden says.
Barber arranged for Gooden to meet with a personal trainer and a nutritionist and prescribed a host of prescription drugs such as testosterone, estrogen and thyroid medication, and the usual array of anti-aging supplements like DHEA and vitamins, most of which she obtains from Barber.
These days, many anti-aging promoters, seeking to shed the flim-flam image, are ratcheting down the rhetoric. They have begun using terms like "age management" and "healthy aging" that imply realistic goals and give important, if commonsense, advice.
Most anti-aging doctors tell patients what we already know: Exercise. Lose weight. Lower our blood pressure. Don't smoke. "I do not see this as the basis for a new practice specialty," argues Relman, the professor emeritus at Harvard.
But a good anti-aging doctor, says Snyder, is more like a devoted personal mountain guide. Rather than cramming sick patients into quickie appointments, he or she will "push you into exercise, get you to join a club, get a personal trainer, a nutritionist to create a full diet to follow and not just for weight loss. They'll direct you to certain supplements, antioxidants, watch the glucose curve to see if you are borderline diabetic. If you go to a regular doctor he will not be as proactive. He'll wait for an event to happen, then treat it. That is what I do in ER medicine."
That kind of preventive care is what Orange County, Calif., entrepreneur and long-time anti-aging advocate David Kekich, 65, says he gets from his anti-aging doctor. Though he did try testosterone therapy for a short time, he was unable to continue because it aggravated pain from a spinal cord injury. Instead, Kekich and his physician have built a program of rigorous exercise; a low-fat diet with abundant fresh fruits and vegetables, little red meat and no sugar or processed flour; regular blood testing; and aggressive supplementation - up to 60 tablets per day.
"I see my doctor about once a year," Kekich reports. "He fine-tunes things. Regular doctors could not even come close. When I have gone to them they tell me I am crazy and should not even look at these things and that I should wait until I have a problem. But to me that is closing the barn door after the horse is gone. Most doctors are mechanics. They fix things. To me, prevention is the name of the game."
Filling a gap Mainstream medicine may look askance at anti-aging practices, but it has adopted its elements. Sterling centers such as Princeton, Stanford, the Cleveland Clinic, Northwestern University, Duke University and others have established "executive health" programs where the wealthy undergo similar day-long evaluations, and testing costing thousands of dollars.
The fact that the wealthy are willing to pay so much, and that doctors are catering to them, is more a comment on the health care system we have built, says Northwestern's Zoloth, than on the validity of anti-aging medicine.
Relman agrees that anti-aging medicine is stepping into the growing gap between the public and faith in the health care system. "It is unfortunate but understandable given the sad facts about the current state of medical care in this country," he says. "Without a strong base of primary care, you cannot have an effective health care system. It breaks down into specialized and unconnected procedures and tests and gets more and more disorganized and unsatisfactory, and that is what is happening in America today."
Though it may fill the gap, much of the anti-aging agenda is still based more on hope than evidence. "We do worry that there could be bad effects 20 or 30 years from now," admits Jurow, referring mainly to hormones.
In the world of anti-aging, though, which sees us all moving closer to death with every passing minute, hope outweighs proof. "We don't have time to wait half a century to find out if something is really going to work!" XX says.
With lawmakers grilling Roger Clemens on Capitol Hill this week about using performance-enhancing drugs, human growth hormone (HGH) is back in the spotlight. Hardly a surprise, given the metronome of such news stories since Jose Canseco published Juiced in 2005, a tell-all tale that alleges widespread steroid use among major leaguers.
What is surprising is how widely human growth hormone is used beyond the arena of athletics. Government investigations such as the U.S. attorney's Operation Phony Pharm and the Albany district attorney's Operation Which Doctor are now highlighting the extent of growth hormone's distribution and use for antiaging purposes. The targets of these investigations are clinics and online marketers who persuade middle-aged and elderly Americans to shell out hundreds of dollars each month for the hormone that, according to boosters, does everything from build bone and muscle mass to improve libido, mood, cognitive function, and sleep quality.
One study estimates that tens and perhaps even hundreds of thousands of Americans now use human growth hormone in this way. Organizations such as the American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine, a group of 11,500 physicians and scientists committed to actively slowing the aging process, give the movement the veneer of scientific credibility, but as Business Weekreports, the antiaging industry remains a magnet for controversy. Distributing prescription human growth hormone "off label" (for purposes other than the few approved indications such as pituitary deficiencies, muscle wasting disease among HIV/AIDS patients, and intestinal failure) for antiaging purposes is technically illegal. However, about a third of human growth hormone prescriptions are used for antiaging or athletic enhancement, a 2005 study published in the Journal of the American Medicine Association estimates. It's also possible to get non-prescription human growth hormone pills and sprays, but the Federal Trade Commission has issued a consumer alert warning that these products are more hype than anything else.
Mainstream medicine certainly doesn't buy in. "Anybody who claims today that human growth hormone can slow, stop, or reverse aging in people is mistaken," says Jay Olshansky, a longevity researcher at the University of Illinois. A recently published study in the Annals of Internal Medicine reviewed the rigorous research on the safety and efficacy of growth hormone in the healthy elderly. Good studies were scarce, but the review found that the hormones do nothing to improve life span, bone mineral density, lipid profiles, insulin resistance, and other markers of health. Moreover, 19 percent of people on growth hormones got carpel tunnel syndrome, compared with 1 percent on placebos; 6 percent of men developed gynecomastia, or enlarged breast tissue, compared with 0 percent on placebos; and 22 percent developed blood sugar level problems compared with 14 percent taking placebos. Swelling was another common side effect.
"The risks of human growth hormone outweigh any possible benefits," says Hau Liu, the Stanford University researcher who led the study, though he points out that it only reviewed selected clinical outcomes. It did not, for example, consider the ability to walk up a flight of stairs or other quality-of-life measures. There was one bright spot for the antiaging industry, though: Lean body mass did increase slightly for older people getting the growth hormone. But, says Liu, they could have done much better by simply working out.
Daily News Dr. David Moore & Bill Manville Don't listen to Sly: HGH could be time bomb in a bottle
Friday, February 1st 2008, 1:17 PM
Bill: Dave, do you believe Sylvester Stallone would actually hype the use of Human Growth Hormone to promote his latest Rambo movie? Once a man is past 40, he said in Time Magazine, HGH "increases the quality of your life." Talk about trying to buy manhood in a bottle!
Dr. Dave: Back in my clinical days, I teamed with ex-NFL lineman Bob Newton to help the Seattle Seahawks fight against this kind of abuse. I also assisted the San Diego Padres' interventionist, Ken Hoyt, when a Major League Baseball player in the Northwest needed help. Even before the current ban on HGH and steroids, the three of us were not alone in our profession in warning pro ball clients that these drugs promote unnatural body growth. We are mammals, not plants in need of Miracle Grow fertilizer.
Bill: "EAT ME," said the cake Alice found in Wonderland, and she turned into a giant - something she never wanted to be. These drugs remind me of when I was drinking. I might say, Well, I’ll have just one after work. Sometimes that was true. But once I ended up in Yuma.
Dr. Dave: Right. You never know what will happen.
Bill: Except this: you don’t get anything for free.
Dr. Dave: Even the Big Pharma companies have begun to point out that the real danger is unwanted growth. The Food and Drug Administration keeps putting out bulletins against the black market HGH flooding our country --
Bill: Fat lot of good, I bet, against the huge demand for the good looks, washboard abs and sexual stamina that HGH seems so magically to provide. And what a slogan they’ve come up with for aspects of manhood: "Size Matters!"
Dr. Dave: But at what hidden price? It can be like adding fertilizer to cancer in your body. Or changes in the body organs, like those involved in insulin and glucose, which can bring on Type 2 Diabetes.
Bill: So when the Australian government arrested Sly for carrying HGH into their country, it wasn’t just some kind of puritanical hypersensitivity to drug use?
Dr. Dave: Nor, when Major League Baseball banned this stuff, was it merely a case of not wanting ball players to have an artificial competitive edge.
Bill: Stallone predicts that in ten years, these drugs will be sold over the counter. How does he know what strange effects HGH may have on his body in ten years - that he himself may not live to be the poster boy against their use?
Dr. Dave: The HGH that Sly tried to bring into Australia, Jintropin, is banned from sale in every country but China. In fact, to get onto a medically monitored high dose HGH regimen needed for real muscle growth in the United States would cost thousands of dollars a month.
Bill: No wonder so much of it is counterfeit. There’s no FDA quality control, but that does not mean offers to sell me these drugs haven’t begun to show up in my e-mail.
Dr. Dave: Well, my spam e-mail runs more towards offers to cleanse my colon, but I would encourage anyone intrigued by the false promise of HGH to skip the dangerous never-never land of magic potions and get into the growing world of sports medicine instead.
Bill: You talking about professional athletes?
Dr. Dave: Plus the 18-hole a week golfer AND the high aerobic ping pong player too. The holistic health research into nutrition, realistic exercise and mental stamina is booming. They might want to walk through the internet portal for San Diego State University’s Center for Optimal Health and Performance to see what clicks with their interest: www.cohp.sdsu.edu.
Bill: Dave, I sometimes think our warnings against addiction resemble those drug company ads on TV -- the ones that show a beautiful boy and girl riding their bikes on a sunny lane through the woods ...
Dr. Dave: ... While we’re the nagging voiceover in the background, saying "side effects can include acne, a busted liver, early death and your ears may fall off."
Bill: Who listens to that?
TIMESUNION.COM
Steroids beyond sports
Celebrities now among those linked to drug shipments
By BRENDAN J. LYONS, Senior writer Click byline for more stories by writer. First published: Sunday, January 13, 2008
PATCHOGUE -- The names of R&B music star Mary J. Blige, along with rap artists 50 Cent, Timbaland and Wyclef Jean, and award-winning author and producer Tyler Perry, have emerged in an Albany-based investigation of steroids trafficking that has already rocked the professional sports world, according to confidential sources.
Information has surfaced recently showing those stars are among tens of thousands of people who may have used or received prescribed shipments of steroids and injectable human growth hormone in recent years. Law enforcement officials have said they have no evidence in their sprawling multistate probe that customers, including Blige or other entertainers, violated any laws. Instead, they are targeting anti-aging clinics, doctors and pharmacists who prescribed the drugs.
Still, medical experts say that use of steroids and human growth hormone -- an estimated $10 billion-a-year operation worldwide -- reaching into the entertainment industry illustrates how pervasive steroids use in the United States has become. It is not unique to athletics, where performance-enhancing drug use has marred many sports. For many celebrities, the lure of hormonal drugs is their supposed, unproven anti-aging effects.
While Congress is preparing to focus on baseball players alleged to have taken the drugs, medical experts are warning that steroids and human growth hormone are being illegally prescribed nationwide at an alarming rate under the misconception they will aid healing, enhance looks, strength and speed, or slow aging.
Records shared with the Times Union and information from several cooperating witnesses on Long Island indicate Blige and other stars were shipped prescribed human growth hormone or steroids -- sometimes under fictitious names -- at hotels, production studios, private residences, an upscale Manhattan fitness club and through the Long Island office of Michael Diamond, a chiropractor affiliated with the celebrities, sources said.
Diamond, who has not been identified as a target in the case or accused of breaking any laws, helps run an anti-aging program at Clay Gym in Manhattan, according to the company's Web site.
The Albany investigation became a nationwide spectacle last February when authorities raided a Palm Beach County wellness center and the offices of Signature Compounding Pharmacy in downtown Orlando. The wellness center's owners and the pharmacy's operators are awaiting trial in Albany on charges related to the sale of millions of dollars worth of prescription drugs, mostly steroids, through a suspected criminal enterprise involving allegedly corrupt physicians and a series of anti-aging "clinics" that advertised predominantly through the Internet.
In the past year the case has netted 10 guilty pleas, including felony convictions of three physicians and several operators of anti-aging clinics in Texas, Florida and New York.
Along the way it has exposed allegations of steroid use by Major League Baseball players, pro wrestlers, NFL figures, police officers, prison guards, top-ranked body builders, people with ties to high school and college wrestling programs, and now, celebrities.
In a brief interview at his Patchtogue office Friday, Diamond said patient privacy laws prohibit him from discussing the stars he has treated or why.
"I don't have anything to do with athletes, I don't do athletes," Diamond said. "Anyone that wants to publicly state that they work with me can do so, it's just I'm not allowed legally to state who I treat or who I don't treat."
Still, it appears evident Diamond caters to famous clients as evidenced by the many stars, including Steven Seagal, whose photographs -- some autographed to Diamond -- adorn his office's walls.
"Because of this recent development as far as what I found out was going on with (Signature) pharmacy I was approached and I was ... told not to discuss anything right now ... because there's investigations going on," Diamond said, not elaborating.
Diamond said he had previously met officials from Signature pharmacy at anti-aging conventions, but that he learned of the year-old criminal case only recently.
Entertainers using steroids is not new. Last year, Hollywood action-film stalwart Sylvester Stallone paid a $2,975 fine in Australia to settle criminal charges he illegally possessed vials of steroids and human growth hormone discovered during a customs inspection of his luggage.
Stallone, 61, said he needed the drugs to treat his body for a slowdown of his pituitary gland production of growth hormone and for the grueling training he's done over the years making films, according to the Australian Associated Press. But taking the substances in an effort to slow aging or promote healing, which is an unproven claim, is not an allowable reason for a physician to prescribe steroids or growth hormone.
Dr. S. Jay Olshansky, an epidemiologist and co-author of a report on growth hormone published in the Journal of the American Medical Association, said celebrities identified as customers is not surprising.
"In the end the story is less about the entertainers and the athletes and more about the people who are providing them with the drugs," Olshansky said. "They can't get those drugs without somebody with a degree giving it to them."
Still, big names draw interest, including in Congress, where hearings are set to begin this week on a report issued last month by former Sen. George Mitchell that exposed widespread steroids abuse in professional baseball.
Sen. Charles Schumer, D-N.Y., is pushing a bill that would make human growth hormone a controlled substance, like anabolic steroids. Human growth hormone currently is not a controlled substance under federal law, which means it is not a crime to possess the drug and the federal government has minimal control over its production and distribution, Schumer said.
Albany County District Attorney David Soares declined to confirm information about, or to comment on, celebrities named in this report.
Soares said his decision more than two years ago to pursue the case was less about exposing the drug use of athletes or celebrities and more about dismantling a drug pipeline that has funneled millions of dollars in steroids and other drugs into New York. The state has some of the strictest prescription laws in the country and prosecutors said it's unlawful here for a physician, even from another state, to prescribe drugs to a New York patient they never examined.
HGH production declines naturally in a person as he or she grows older. Pharmaceutical versions of the hormone cannot be taken orally and must be injected.
Olshansky, a professor of epidemiology at the University of Illinois' Chicago School of Public Health, said federal regulations also make it illegal for a physician to prescribe growth hormone to a patient he hasn't examined. In order to diagnose a patient with growth hormone deficiency, a rare condition affecting about one in 10,000 people, the physician must conduct a time-consuming, expensive test in which hormones are intravenously infused in patients while monitoring their pituitary gland.
"These doctors who are administering growth hormone without ever seeing patients should be in jail," Olshansky said. "The risks are documented."
Soares, who is in his inaugural term as district attorney, compares the Internet-fueled industry to the powerful cocaine cartels of the 1980s. He pointed out that Stan and Naomi Loomis, the husband and wife owners of the brick-and-mortar Signature pharmacy, own multimillion dollar properties and a fleet of expensive sports cars and boats.
"They're living the lifestyle of the Tony Montanas of the '70s and '80s because they're drug dealers," Soares said, referring to the character made famous by Al Pacino in the movie Scarface. "Our purpose here is more regulation. We want consistency state-to-state and we want tougher regulation over this cyber-economy that right now pretty much anyone with a computer can go out and obtain ... things that shouldn't be obtained without the control or observation of a treating physician."
Signature's attorneys have scoffed at the prosecutor's characterization of their business, claiming no laws were violated because doctors signed the prescriptions they processed.
Dr. Thomas Perls, an internist and associate professor of medicine at Boston University Medical Center, specializes in the study of aging and co-wrote the report on human growth hormone with Olshansky. Perls said industry estimates show that tens of thousands of people nationwide are injecting themselves with steroids and growth hormone, a dangerous drug that he said is routinely and illegally prescribed for anti-aging purposes.
The drug, which is normally used to treat children who suffer rare growth defects, may cause a person to age faster, Perls said. It also can trigger cancer, diabetes, arthritis and other health problems. If someone with cancerous cells takes the drug it's akin to throwing gas on a fire, Olshansky and Perls both said.
"If you look at the dollar amounts that are trading hands here there has to be thousands of people who are doing this and to call it a public health crisis is right on the money," Perls said. "The impact is lost a little bit if people think we're just dealing with a few folks who show up in People magazine."
According to records reviewed by the Times Union, Blige and the other stars received prescriptions that allegedly were signed by Dr. Gary Brandwein, a South Florida osteopath who has pleaded not guilty in Albany to a felony indictment charging him with various drug-related crimes.
Brandwein, through his attorney, Terence Kindlon, declined comment.
According to sources familiar with the investigation, Diamond was questioned recently by state Health Department investigators because he has done business with Anthony Forgione, a former New York Police Department officer arrested last November on charges of selling steroids through a Delray Beach, Fla., anti-aging clinic, Infinity Longevity.
Brandwein, free on bond since his arrest 10 months ago, drew national attention last summer when it was reported he'd previously prescribed steroids for Chris Benoit, a pro wrestler who murdered his wife and son at their Georgia home before committing suicide. Authorities said Benoit had 10 times the normal levels of testosterone in his body at the time though there's no evidence steroids played a role.
Brendan J. Lyons can be reached at 454-5547 or by e-mail at blyons@timesunion.com.
Growth hormone and associated proteins could be responsible for promoting many types of cancer, according to an Australian researcher.
Professor Mike Waters, from the Institute for Molecular Bioscience at The University of Queensland, said that blocking growth hormone action could be a useful avenue for cancer therapy.
He made the comments in a review published in the October 2007 issue of American scientific journal Endocrinology. His review found that many studies have reported a link between growth hormone and cancer, and a recent analysis found that people lacking growth hormone function are resistant to malignancies.
“There is also evidence that blocking growth hormone action can reduce both size and number of tumours,” Professor Waters said.
The review backed up Professor Waters' own research, published in August in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA, which found growth hormone receptor could induce tumour growth when sent to the cell nucleus.
Growth hormone receptor is the protein that cells use to sense growth hormone, which determines the extent of growth after birth, and regulates metabolism.
Growth hormone receptor works from the surface of the cell, but can also be found in places within the cell, including the nucleus.
“Nuclear-localised growth hormone receptor has been reported in a number of cancers previously,” Professor Waters said. “But no one had analysed the consequences of this until our study.”
Professor Waters and his team found that nuclear localisation of growth hormone receptor is definitely associated with increased cell proliferation and spreading of malignant cells, leading to cancer.
“Cells need to multiply in order for us to grow, and it is growth hormone that triggers this proliferation,” Professor Waters said. “But if the cells multiply too quickly and aggressively, it can be dangerous for the body, and result in disorders such as cancer, so we have an in-built brake that stops the cells from proliferating too much.”
“When we sent growth hormone receptor into the nucleus of cells in mice, we found that this brake stopped working, the cells multiplied at a greater rate and tumours began to appear.”
Professor Waters said the ability of nuclear-localised growth hormone receptor to trigger tumour formation could have important clinical implications.
“Our findings indicate that nuclear growth hormone receptor could be targeted to treat proliferative disorders such as cancer, and strategies aimed at stopping growth hormone receptor from moving to the nucleus could result in useful cancer therapeutics. More generally, blocking growth hormone action in the adult should reduce the spread of cancer within the body without major side effects.” Dr. Perls: See the abstract in the Proceedings National Academy Sciences: Nuclear targeting of the growth hormone receptor results in dysregulation of cell proliferation and tumorigenesis, Becky L. Conway-Campbell et al.
Posted on: Wednesday, 11 April 2007, 06:00 CDT
Anti-Aging Clinics Proliferate in Florida
FORT LAUDERDALE, Fla. _ Oasis Longevity & Rejuvenation topped its Internet pages with a photo of a well-muscled man to help sell its human growth hormone shots. The Boca Raton, Fla., clinic is now shut down, its principals charged last month with selling the drugs illegally. But the business of selling hormones claiming they build hard muscle, burn flab and reverse the effects of aging has been a lucrative _ and controversial _ staple for years in South Florida. Dozens of clinics make millions yearly selling hormones, often venturing into gray areas of medicine and the law, prosecutors and physicians say. Among the sellers are a former cocaine dealer and a former merchant of illegal steroids."It's a huge business because people want the fountain of youth," said Dr. Paul Jellinger, an advisor to the American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists. "They're just disregarding the fact that there's no proof that it works. (Also,) this stuff can hurt you."Two sets of arrests this year showed the underside of the business. In February, 14 people running seven Internet pharmacies in South Florida were indicted by a federal grand jury, accused of selling drugs without the patients visiting a doctor. In Florida and many states, it's illegal to prescribe or sell a drug unless the doctor first sees the patient in person. Then, last month, officials from Albany, N.Y., arrested 15 people, including eight in South Florida, suspected of selling hormones and steroids to buyers _ a few of them pro athletes _ without a doctor visit. The ring centered on Signature Pharmacy in Orlando, which was charged in the case and sold $40 million of the drugs last year, said Christopher Baynes, an assistant district attorney in Albany. Signature's top source of customers: Palm Beach Rejuvenation Center, an anti-aging clinic in Palm BeachGardens that accounted for $15 million of the business, said Baynes. Officials arrested two of the clinic owners and its doctor, plus six others at Oasis and online site medxlife.com, which each accounted for millions of the revenue. The principals at Signature and the clinics have pleaded not guilty and declined to comment. Signature sold to at least two dozen South Florida clinics. Said Baynes: "There are more out there involved with Signature. I don't know whether more will be charged."Among the names to surface in connection to the case: Palm Beach Life Extension in Palm BeachGardens. An Albany agent said in a document the clinic is separate but "under the control" of Palm Beach Rejuvenation and sold drugs illegally. The Health and RejuvenationCenter in Palm BeachGardens. At least one co-owner used to work at Palm Beach Rejuvenation, attorneys and other clinic operators said. Infinity Rejuvenation in Deerfield Beach. A doctor was arrested in Albany on charges she signed illegal prescriptions from the clinic. Metragen Pharmaceuticals in Deerfield Beach. In documents, Albany agents said some of Signature's illegal prescriptions came from Metragen. The company's founding principal started it after his former pharmacy, Powermedica, was shut down in 2005 for illegally selling steroids. The owners of those four businesses have not been charged. Officials or attorneys for the four declined to comment or could not be reached with calls to their offices. Hormone sellers said Signature was the biggest single supplier in South Florida and aggressively recruited clinics that sent them the customers. "Signature solicited everyone, from the small sites to the big sites to the individual doctors," said Mark White, director at Anti-Aging Group Health in Aventura who said he did not use Signature. In affidavits, agents said clinics in the Albany case used Web sites and ads to attract patients who filled out medical forms and got blood tests, but never saw a doctor. A clinic doctor wrote a prescription, which was filled by Signature and shipped to the patient. The Oasis marketing director, Aaron J. Peterson, told a judge when he pleaded guilty March 28 that the clinic paid Signature $10,000 for finding a doctor who signed prescriptions without seeing patients. Owners of another South Florida clinic also paid Signature to line up a doctor, and paid the doctor thousands per month for signing prescriptions, said the clinic's attorney, John Contini. He spoke on the condition his clients not be named. "These physicians were abdicating their duty to the patient," Contini said. Contini said Signature also sent his clients to an attorney who, for $1,500, assured them the operation was legal. South Florida "anti-aging" clinics have been selling human growth hormones, or HGH, since the 1990s. The owners grasped onto a few small studies suggesting that symptoms of aging declined after shots of HGH, which is made by the pituitary gland to control metabolism. Clinics began claiming that taking HGH or testosterone can erase fatigue, body fat, muscle loss, low sex drive, even gray hair. Muscle-builders craved it. "It's hormone replacement therapy, to make people feel better," said Jeffrey George, owner of SouthBeach Rejuvenation in West Palm Beach. "Females have menopause and no one complains about them getting hormones. Men have `andropause' and we prescribe hormones for them." The cost: Up to $1,000 a month. Specialists and federal officials say it's medically correct to use HGH for patients who no longer produce it, which normally is caused by trauma or pituitary tumors. But there's no proof shots help when HGH declines naturally, experts said. "Hormone levels go down as we get older. That's somehow how nature figured out how to do it," said Dr. Michael Karl, a specialist at the University of Miami medical school. What's more, doctors said studies show that having too much HGH for one's age can cause heart disease, high blood pressure, diabetes and muscle and joint pain, and possibly spur cancer cells. Some HGH proponents contend that most older patients need shots because they have low levels in their blood. But physician experts said a low level means little because HGH fluctuates and drops near zero daily. Albany prosecutor Baynes said clinics in his case sold HGH to patients with normal test results. Brian Cotugno, who used to be a consultant to HGH clinics, said many would not stop selling to patients with normal lab tests because they would lose millions in sales to those using it for non-medical reasons."A lot of their business was (from customers) who just wanted to call and order substances over the phone," Cotugno said. Cotugno said he got into the business a few years ago, after a 10-year sentence for cocaine trafficking, which he called a mistake at age 22. He started his own clinic, Maxim Rejuvenation in West Palm Beach, Fla. Maxim was one of eight entities dropped last month from a list of approved online pharmacies by the accreditation group Pharmacy Checker, said its vice president, Gabriel Levitt. After the Albany arrests, the nonprofit group no longer accredits online pharmacies that sell or promote HGH, he said. "It's not safe," Levitt said, "to get prescriptions online for controlled substances or growth hormones."___ MORE ABOUT STEROIDS, HGH AND SUPPLEMENTS Testosterone: An anabolic steroid, the male sex hormone promotes tissue growth. Doctors prescribe it when the body fails to make it. No large-scale research shows whether it can combat age-related changes. Excess amounts can cause sterility, spur prostate cancer and worsen sleep apnea. Hormone pills, sprays: Some sellers offer HGH as a pill or an oral or nasal spray instead of as an injection. Less is known about the possible benefits compared with injectable HGH. Natural supplements: Some sellers promote nonprescription protein supplements, amino acids and other substances they contend will spark the body to produce more hormones. No one regulates these, and there's little data whether they work or are harmful. Sources: American Association of Clinical Endocrinologists, American Academy of Anti-Aging Medicine, HarvardMedicalSchool, WebMD.com
____WHAT IS HGH? "Anti-aging" clinics and doctors promote many hormone products they contend will eradicate fatigue, muscle loss, flab, declining sex drive and other symptoms of aging: Human growth hormone: The pituitary gland makes HGH (somatropin) to govern muscle and bone growth. Doctors prescribe synthetic HGH shots if the body fails to make it. No large-scale research shows if it can combat age-related changes. Some body-builders seek it to add muscle. Excess amounts can cause heart disease, diabetes and possibly promote cancer.___ (c) 2007 South Florida Sun-Sentinel. Visit the Sun-Sentinel on the World Wide Web at http://www.sun-sentinel.com/ Source: South Florida Sun-Sentinel
Baby boomers pay for six pack in a syringe
By Philip Sherwell, Sunday Telegraph
Last Updated: 1:00am BST 19/08/2007
With his six-pack stomach, bulging chest and bull-like shoulders, the muscleman in the newspaper advertisement displays the sort of rippling torso that adorns the cover of men's fitness journals.
But there is one difference. From the neck up, Dr Jeffry S Life is a balding 67-year-old physician. His physique is the product not of a computer touch-up but a controversial American "ageing management" technique, that often includes a cocktail of human growth hormones and testosterone.
Some 13,000 clients have so far spent thousands of dollars on a technique known as Cenegenics (from the Greek for "new beginning"). As post-war baby boomers enter their 60s, it promises to boost performance from the office to the gym to the bedroom.
The initial one-day $2,995 evaluation at the Cenegenics Medical Institute (CMI) in Las Vegas, has already attracted a handful of unnamed Britons seeking the secret of Dr Life's remarkable torso.
However, unlike many other health fads, there is one reason why it may not prove popular.
Cenegenics was the brainchild of Alan Mintz, a radiologist, whose own buffed body also used to be the best advertising for his business - until he died in June, aged 69, five years short of the average male American life expectancy.
His death prompted internet speculation that he paid the ultimate price for using human growth hormones. But the CMI has been at pains to assert that Dr Mintz's passing was the result of a brain haemorrhage. His decline was due to an accident in the gym, according to Dr Life, his friend and personal physician, who also works for Cenegenics in Las Vegas.
After the initial evaluation, clients spend up to $13,000 on exercise and diet regimes, supplemented by vitamins and, in most cases, hormone replenishment such as testosterone.
Approximately 20 per cent are also prescribed injections of human growth hormones if they are diagnosed as demonstrating adult growth hormone deficiency (AGHD).
Critics say that it is unproven and potentially dangerous. Tom Perls, a professor of medicine at Boston University, expressed surprise at the number of Cenegenics clients diagnosed with AGHD, as he said the condition normally affects three people in 10,000.
In an interview outlining his philosophy last year, Dr Mintz listed a panoply of positives that he attributed to human growth hormone. They include a decrease in fat and skin wrinkling, an increase in muscle and improved mood.
"Next year does not have to be worse than this year," Dr Mintz said. "How about good sexual activity with your loved one once a week, twice a week, feeling good about it?"
¤
January, 2007 FDA clarifies that it is illegal to prescribe, in addition to distribute or provide GH for antiaging or athletic uses
A January 23rd, 2007 "Detention Without Physical Examination (DWPE) Alert" clearly states, perhaps more than ever before, that it is not only illegal to market, provide or distribute GH for anti-aging and athletic use, it is also illegal for doctors to prescribe it for these uses and for anyone to market it for these uses. Following, is the key text.